One Iota

c. AD 435

In the Mass: The Prayer of the Faithful

Why pray for other people to believe?

In the Mass
Restored after the Second Vatican Council; kept for centuries in the Good Friday prayers
Roots
1 Timothy 2:1–2; Justin, c. AD 155; Prosper, c. AD 435
initium fidei“the beginning of faith” (Council of Orange, 529)

Marseille, around 428. The monks of southern Gaul are uneasy about Augustine’s teaching that even the first stirrings of faith are God’s gift; surely, they argue, the first step must be ours. A layman named Prosper, alarmed, writes to Augustine in Africa to warn him. He will spend the rest of his life defending grace, and his most famous argument will come not from a theology book but from the Church’s prayers.

After the Creed we pray for the Church, the world, those who suffer and our own community. It is an ancient practice: Paul asks for prayers “for everyone, for kings and all in authority” (1 Timothy 2:1–2), and Justin describes Christians praying together for all people everywhere. It faded from the Roman Mass for centuries, surviving mainly in the great prayers of Good Friday, and was restored after the Second Vatican Council.

It also gave us a famous principle. In the early fifth century, followers of the monk Pelagius taught, roughly, that we can turn to God by our own strength, with grace merely helping. Around 435 Prosper answered from the liturgy: look at what the Church does! Everywhere, priests pray for unbelievers to receive faith and for sinners to repent. You don’t ask God for what you could simply do yourself. His conclusion became the slogan: the law of prayer establishes the law of belief.

Pelagius has modern heirs. In 2018 Pope Francis warned of a “new Pelagianism” that treats holiness as a self-improvement project.

The one iota

grace that helps, or grace that gives

Pelagius could say that grace helps us. The Church insisted that grace gives: even the first desire to believe is God’s gift, as the Council of Orange taught in 529. The difference sounds tiny, since God is involved either way. But one makes the first step ours, and the other makes it his.

If the iota slipped

If grace only helps, the first step towards God is ours, and faith becomes an achievement. The unexpected casualties are humility and hope: those who succeed grow proud, and those who struggle despair, because everything seems to depend on them. It also changes how we see unbelievers: as people who haven’t tried hard enough, rather than people God is still seeking. The Church’s prayer for them expresses the opposite conviction.

Why it still matters

The General Instruction sets out the order of the intercessions: for the Church, for public authorities and the salvation of the world, for those in need, and for the local community. It is the order Paul asked for in 1 Timothy 2, and the order of the ancient solemn prayers still sung on Good Friday. Justin describes the newly baptised joining these prayers for the first time. That is why they are the Prayer of the Faithful: the prayer of the baptised, exercising the priesthood they received at the font.

Chew on this

If God already knows what we need, why ask him for anything at all?

Some ways to answer

Not to inform God, but to be changed. Augustine wrote that God doesn’t need our prayers to learn our wishes; prayer stretches our desire, so that we can receive what he wants to give.

Intercession also expresses the communion of the Church. God chooses to act through the prayers of his people, as he acted through Moses’ outstretched arms. Asking is not a lack of faith but the form faith takes, and praying for others is a way of loving people we cannot otherwise reach.

Sources

What this bite draws on.

Further reading

To take the question further.

This is one of fifty five-minute bites in One Iota, an introduction to the people of the early Church and the prayers we still say at Mass.