AD 431
A title for Mary, a question about Jesus
When Nestorius, the new archbishop of Constantinople, backed a preacher who said Mary should not be called Theotokos, “God-bearer”, his congregation reportedly erupted. Nestorius preferred Christotokos, “Christ-bearer”. It sounds tidier. God isn’t born, surely?
Cyril of Alexandria saw the problem. If Mary gave birth to a man in whom God dwelt, then there are two “someones” in Christ, and the one who died on the Cross was not God at all. Whether Nestorius truly meant this is still debated; Ephesus rejected the idea.
At Ephesus in 431 the council sided with Cyril, and the people of the city are said to have escorted the bishops home by torchlight. The title is about Mary; the truth it protects is about Jesus: one person, truly God, who was truly born and truly died for us. (Cyril, it must be said, was brilliant and not always nice. Saints come in many flavours.)
The one iota
Theotokos / Christotokos
Change one part of the word and the meaning shifts. Christotokos, “Christ-bearer”, is true as far as it goes, but leaves open whether the one Mary bore is God. Theotokos closes the door: the child in her arms is the eternal Son. The Hail Mary says it daily: “Holy Mary, Mother of God”.
If the iota slipped
Christotokos on its own would allow two “someones” in Christ: a man born of Mary, and the Word dwelling in him. Then the one who died on the Cross was a man, not God, and his death could not save the world. Unexpectedly, withholding the title from Mary ends up demoting Jesus. It would also mean God never truly entered human life from its very beginning, in a womb and a birth; he would only have visited a human being.
Why it still matters
Ephesus left visible marks on Catholic worship. Within a few years Pope Sixtus III rebuilt Rome’s great Marian basilica, St Mary Major, its mosaics celebrating the Mother of God. Since 1970 the Roman calendar has opened each civil year, on 1 January, with the Solemnity of Mary, Mother of God, on the octave day of Christmas. The feast of her title falls, fittingly, inside the celebration of her Son’s birth.
Chew on this
Why has honouring Mary so often protected belief that Jesus is God?
Some ways to answer
Because Mary’s titles are statements about who her Son is. “Mother of God” only makes sense if the child she bore is God. Marian feasts and prayers keep repeating that the eternal Son really became human in a real woman’s womb; the Hail Mary says it every day.
The Catechism puts it simply: what the Church believes about Mary rests on what she believes about Christ, and what she teaches about Mary sheds light in turn on her faith in Christ.
Sources
What this bite draws on.
- Socrates, Church History 7.32 (the uproar over Theotokos)
- Cyril of Alexandria, Second Letter to Nestorius (Cyril’s case against Nestorius)
- Council of Ephesus (431), acts (the council’s decisions)
- Catholic Church and Assyrian Church of the East, Common Christological Declaration (1994) (agreement on Christ)
- Liber Pontificalis, Life of Sixtus III (St Mary Major rebuilt)
Further reading
To take the question further.
- Luke 1:43 (“the mother of my Lord”)
- Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium 52–66
- CCC 487 and 495