AD 451
Four “withouts” and a pope’s letter
October 451. In the church of St Euphemia at Chalcedon, across the Bosporus from Constantinople, hundreds of bishops sit in rows, with imperial officials presiding from the nave. A letter from Pope Leo, known as the Tome, is read aloud in Greek. When it ends, the bishops are said to have cried out: “Peter has spoken through Leo!” Two years earlier, a council at Ephesus had backed the elderly monk Eutyches, who taught that Christ’s humanity was swallowed up by his divinity, leaving one nature. Now the tide turned.
The council’s definition is famous for what it refuses to say. Christ is one person in two natures: without confusion, without change, without division, without separation. Think of the four “withouts” as guardrails on a mountain road. They don’t explain the view, but they stop you driving off either cliff: a Jesus who is only a great man, or a God merely dressed up as one.
The aftermath was not tidy. Much of Egypt and Syria rejected Chalcedon, a split that modern dialogue suggests was partly about words and politics.
The one iota
ek / en: “from” two natures, or “in” two natures
An early draft at Chalcedon said Christ was “from two natures”, which Eutyches’ sympathisers could accept: two natures before the union, one after. The final definition says “in two natures”. In Greek that is ek versus en, two tiny prepositions, and the difference still divides Christians today.
If the iota slipped
“From two natures”, in the sense Eutyches gave it, meant one nature after the union, with Christ’s humanity absorbed into his divinity. Then his hunger, fear and tears were not quite human, and neither was his risen body. The unexpected casualty is our own resurrection: if the body that rose was no longer truly human, it is no pledge that ours will rise. (The Oriental Orthodox churches, who kept the older phrasing, reject Eutyches too, which is why today’s dialogue has found common ground.)
Why it still matters
Pope Leo’s Tome made Chalcedon possible, and his preaching still reaches Catholics every Christmas. On Christmas Day the Office of Readings gives his sermon on the Nativity, with its famous line: “Christian, remember your dignity.” Leo’s point is Chalcedon’s: because the Son took our nature without ceasing to be God, human nature itself has been raised. The Catechism opens its teaching on the Christian moral life with the same words.
Chew on this
Which is the more tempting mistake today: Jesus as just a great teacher, or Jesus as God in a human costume?
Some ways to answer
In the wider culture, the first: Jesus as a wise teacher and moral example, but not Lord. Among believers, the second can creep in unnoticed: a Jesus who never really struggled, learned, tired or was tempted, which makes him distant and his example out of reach.
Chalcedon rules out both, and each matters. If he isn’t God, he cannot save; if he isn’t fully human, he hasn’t saved all of us. Gregory of Nazianzus: what was not assumed was not healed. Hebrews adds the pastoral point: we have a high priest who can sympathise with our weaknesses, tested in every way yet without sin.
Sources
What this bite draws on.
- Leo the Great, Tome to Flavian (the letter read at the council)
- Council of Chalcedon (451), acts (“Peter has spoken through Leo”)
- Council of Chalcedon (451), the Chalcedonian Definition (the four “withouts”)
- Gregory of Nazianzus, Letter 101 (what was not assumed was not healed)
- Hebrews 4:15 (tested in every way, yet without sin)
- Leo the Great, Sermon 21 (“Christian, remember your dignity”)
Further reading
To take the question further.