One Iota

c. AD 325

The books that were spoken against

ἀντιλεγόμεναantilegomena, “spoken against”: the disputed books

Caesarea, on the coast of Palestine, around 325. In the library founded by Origen and enlarged by the martyr Pamphilus, the bishop Eusebius is writing the first history of the Church. When he reaches the books of the New Testament, he does something unusually honest: he reports not only what the churches agree on, but where they still disagree.

He sorts the books into groups. The four Gospels, Acts, the letters of Paul, 1 John and 1 Peter are acknowledged everywhere. James, Jude, 2 Peter, and 2 and 3 John are accepted by most but disputed by some. Revelation he lists, awkwardly, in two places at once, because opinion about it was so divided. Books such as the Shepherd of Hermas and the Didache he counts as orthodox but not Scripture, and others, like the so-called Gospel of Peter, he rejects outright as heretical.

So the canon wasn’t dropped from heaven as a finished list, nor voted in by one council. It was recognised over centuries, as churches compared what they had received from the apostles and what they read at the Eucharist. The disputed books took longest, and some of them are ones we now hear every year.

The one iota

antilegomena: “spoken against”

Eusebius’s word for the disputed books, antilegomena, is not a verdict of rejection. It records that some churches doubted them while most received them. The alternatives would have been to hide the disagreement, presenting a tidy list as though it had always existed, or to treat any doubt as disqualifying.

If the iota slipped

A tidy, invented history would make the canon look like a committee decision, and it would collapse the first time anyone read the sources. Treating every doubt as fatal would have cost the Church the Letter of James, with its insistence that faith without works is dead, and Revelation, the book of the Lamb’s victory. The unexpected lesson is that honesty about the process strengthens trust in the result: the Church took its time, compared notes, and received what came from the apostles.

Why it still matters

The test Eusebius and his contemporaries applied, what the churches had received from the apostles and read in their assemblies, still shows in Catholic practice. James, 2 Peter, Jude and Revelation, once disputed, are all proclaimed in the Lectionary; in Year C, Revelation supplies the second reading through the Sundays of Easter. Writings like the Didache, which Eusebius valued but did not count as Scripture, have their place instead in the Office of Readings, where the Church still reads the Fathers alongside the Bible.

Chew on this

Does it trouble you that the canon took centuries to settle?

Some ways to answer

It needn’t. The Church existed before the New Testament was written, and it worshipped, preached and suffered long before any list was fixed. The canon is the Church recognising which writings carried the apostles’ witness, not inventing an authority out of nothing.

The slow process was also a safeguard. Books had to prove themselves in the life of many churches over generations, and no single bishop or emperor could simply decree them in or out. That is part of why the result has held.

Sources

What this bite draws on.

  • Eusebius, Church History 3.25 (acknowledged, disputed and rejected books)
  • Eusebius, Church History 6.12 (Serapion and the Gospel of Peter)
  • Eusebius, Church History 6.32 (the library at Caesarea)
  • Lectionary for Mass, Year C, Sundays of Easter (Revelation as the second reading) (background)
  • Liturgy of the Hours, Office of Readings (the Fathers read alongside Scripture) (background)

Further reading

To take the question further.

This is one of fifty five-minute bites in One Iota, an introduction to the people of the early Church and the prayers we still say at Mass.