One Iota

AD 325

The heresy with a catchy tune

γεννηθέντα, οὐ ποιηθέντα“begotten, not made” (Creed of Nicaea)

Arius, a priest of Alexandria, was talented, devout and good at marketing. He reportedly set his theology to popular songs for sailors, millers and travellers: the fourth-century version of a jingle you can’t get out of your head.

The trouble was the lyrics. The Son, Arius taught, was the first and greatest thing God ever made. But made. “There was when he was not.”

In 325 the bishops met at Nicaea and chose a blunt, unbiblical word to close the door: the Son is homoousios, of the same substance as the Father. (The story that St Nicholas slapped Arius there is a much later legend. Sorry.) Why the fuss? Because, as Athanasius saw, only God can bring us to God. A creature, however glorious, cannot save you, and worshipping one would be idolatry.

The one iota

gennētos / genētos: begotten or made

Here the key difference really was one letter. In fourth-century Greek, gennētos (two n’s) is linked to “begotten”, while genētos (one n) means “come into being”, that is, made. Arius’s theology blurred them; the Creed separates them in plain words: “begotten, not made”. A son shares his father’s nature; a thing someone makes does not.

If the iota slipped

If the Son were made rather than begotten, God would not be Father from all eternity: there would have been a time when God was alone, with no one to love. The unexpected casualty is “God is love” (1 John 4:8), since love needs a beloved. Athanasius pressed the first point, that God is eternally Father; later writers such as Augustine drew out the second. It would also make our adoption as God’s children impossible. We can share the Son’s relationship with the Father only if he is truly Son by nature, not a creature with a title.

Why it still matters

Arius’s slogan, “there was when he was not”, left its mark on a prayer Catholics say every day. In 529 a council at Vaison in southern Gaul required the words “as it was in the beginning” to be sung in the Glory Be, precisely because heretics claimed the Son had not always existed with the Father. Every decade of the Rosary, and almost every psalm in the Divine Office, still ends with that small anti-Arian clause.

Chew on this

What would change in your prayer if Jesus were the greatest creature rather than God?

Some ways to answer

Almost everything. We could admire, thank and imitate him, but not worship him. Praying to him, adoring him in the Eucharist, and singing “Glory to the Father, and to the Son” would all be idolatry.

Salvation itself would change. A creature can show us the way to God, but cannot unite us with God, because only God can share God’s own life. Athanasius’s point: the Son became one of us so that we might share in the divine nature (2 Peter 1:4). If the Son is less than God, the bridge doesn’t reach the other bank.

Play it out

In Was There a Time?, a One Iota game, you are the new bishop of a small see in Palestine as the Arian crisis builds towards Nicaea. Where will you stand, and what will it cost you?

Sources

What this bite draws on.

Further reading

To take the question further.

This is one of fifty five-minute bites in One Iota, an introduction to the people of the early Church and the prayers we still say at Mass.