c. AD 155
In the Mass: The Great Amen
The Amen that sounded like thunder
- In the Mass
- The people’s Amen, c. AD 155 (Justin)
- Roots
- Israel’s “Amen, Amen” (Nehemiah 8:6)
Rome, around 155. Justin lives in rooms above a bathhouse, where he teaches anyone who comes to him. On Sundays he joins the city’s Christians for the Eucharist. When the presider has finished the long prayer of thanksgiving over the bread and the cup, the whole room answers with one Hebrew word, Amen, and the deacons begin to distribute.
Every Eucharistic Prayer ends the same way. The priest lifts up the Body and Blood of Christ and says or sings: “Through him, and with him, and in him, O God, almighty Father, in the unity of the Holy Spirit, all glory and honour is yours, for ever and ever.” And the people answer: Amen.
Justin singles out that Amen: all the people present give their assent. Two centuries later Jerome wrote that in the churches of Rome the Amen rang out like heavenly thunder. Whether your parish produces thunder or a polite murmur may depend on the day.
The one iota
hosē dynamis: “as he is able”
Justin says the presider offers prayers and thanksgiving “as he is able”: early Eucharistic prayers were often improvised within a familiar pattern, and the people’s Amen sealed them. The Apostolic Tradition allowed a bishop to pray in his own words, provided the prayer was orthodox. By 393 the Council of Hippo required anyone composing new prayers to have them checked by more learned brethren before use, and fixed, approved texts gradually became the norm.
If the iota slipped
Improvisation isn’t wrong in itself, and the early Church lived with it. But the risk showed quickly: a Eucharistic prayer can carry heresy as easily as faith, and the people’s Amen then ratifies whatever was said. The unexpected casualty of an improvised or altered Eucharistic Prayer is the congregation itself, asked to sign something it has had no chance to trust. Approved texts protect the people’s Amen.
Why it still matters
That is why the Church today permits only approved Eucharistic Prayers, and why the doxology is left to the priest while the Amen belongs to the people: each keeps its place. Because the Amen is the people’s ratification, the Church encourages singing it; the 1967 instruction on sacred music placed the final doxology and its Amen among the parts of the Mass most worth singing. As it is sung, the priest raises the paten and chalice together, showing the offering the people are affirming.
Chew on this
Why is the Great Amen often called the most important response of the people?
Some ways to answer
Because it ratifies the whole Eucharistic Prayer, the heart of the Mass. The priest has prayed in the name of all; the Amen is the people making that prayer their own.
Sources
What this bite draws on.
- Martyrdom of Justin, Chariton, and other Roman Martyrs (his rooms above the baths)
- Justin Martyr, First Apology 65 and 67 (the people’s Amen)
- Jerome, Commentary on Galatians, preface to book 2 (the Amen like thunder)
- Apostolic Tradition 9 (praying in one’s own words)
- Council of Hippo (393), canon 21 (new prayers checked before use)
- Sacred Congregation of Rites, Musicam Sacram (1967) 29 (the Amen among the parts to be sung)
- GIRM 79h and 151 (the doxology and the Amen)
Further reading
To take the question further.