One Iota

c. AD 155

In the Mass: The homily

The first homily was one sentence long

In the Mass
Described by Justin, c. AD 155
Roots
Jesus in the synagogue at Nazareth (Luke 4), c. AD 30
σήμερονsēmeron, “today” (Luke 4:21)

In the synagogue at Nazareth, Jesus stood up, read from the prophet Isaiah, rolled up the scroll, sat down and said: “Today this scripture has been fulfilled in your hearing” (Luke 4:21). One sentence. By the end of the visit the congregation was trying to throw him off a cliff, so not every homily lands.

That is the pattern the Church kept: Scripture read, then explained and applied to today. Justin describes it around 155: after the readings, the presider urges the people to imitate the good things they have heard. The Fathers were formidable preachers. John of Constantinople was so eloquent that later generations called him Chrysostom, “golden mouth”, and Augustine’s hundreds of surviving sermons show him chatting, teasing and occasionally asking his listeners to stay awake.

The one iota

“Today”

Jesus’ one-sentence homily turns on a single word: sēmeron, “today”. Not “one day”, not “long ago”. Origen, preaching on this passage in the third century, told his congregation that the same fulfilment was happening in their own assembly, and wished that their eyes, too, were fixed on Jesus. The alternatives are to treat Scripture as a record of the past, or as a promise only for the future.

If the iota slipped

Without “today”, preaching slides into one of three familiar forms: a history lecture, a moral pep talk, or commentary on current affairs. Each misses the point, that the Scriptures are being fulfilled now, in this congregation. The unexpected casualty is the link between word and sacrament: a homily that doesn’t lead towards the altar leaves the Eucharist feeling like an add-on to a talk, rather than the place where the word just heard is fulfilled.

Why it still matters

The Fathers preached through whole books of the Bible, reading by reading: Chrysostom’s homilies on Matthew and Romans, Augustine’s on John and the Psalms. That practice is why the Church today asks that the homily be drawn from the readings or the texts of the Mass, given on Sundays and holy days, and normally preached by a priest or deacon. It is also why Vatican II deliberately spoke of the “homily” rather than the “sermon”: both words originally meant simply a talk, but “sermon” had come to mean preaching on any topic, often felt as a pause in the Mass, whereas a homily is part of the liturgy itself.

Chew on this

What makes a good homily, and whose job is it to make it fruitful?

Some ways to answer

The Church asks that a homily explain the readings or texts of the Mass, apply them to people’s lives, and lead them towards the Eucharist. Pope Francis devoted a long section of Evangelii Gaudium to preaching, asking for homilies that are brief, well prepared and warm, like a mother speaking to her children.

Listening is an art too. Augustine told his people that the preacher is only the outer voice; the true teacher speaks within. A congregation that comes prepared, having read the readings beforehand, hears far more.

Sources

What this bite draws on.

Further reading

To take the question further.

This is one of fifty five-minute bites in One Iota, an introduction to the people of the early Church and the prayers we still say at Mass.