c. AD 155
A philosopher describes Sunday Mass
Justin shopped around for a philosophy. He tried a Stoic, an Aristotelian, a Pythagorean and the Platonists, until an old man walking by the sea pointed him to the prophets and to Christ. He became a Christian and, famously, kept wearing his philosopher’s cloak.
Around 155 he wrote to the emperor to explain what Christians actually do. On the day of the sun, he says, we gather. The memoirs of the apostles and the writings of the prophets are read. The presider preaches. We stand and pray. Bread, and wine mixed with water, are brought forward. The presider gives thanks at length, and the people answer “Amen”. Deacons take communion to those who are absent.
This food, Justin insists, is not ordinary bread and drink, but the flesh and blood of the incarnate Jesus. Read him next to the Order of Mass. It is uncanny.
The one iota
“not as ordinary bread”
Justin writes that Christians receive the Eucharist “not as ordinary bread and ordinary drink”, but as the flesh and blood of Jesus, made so “by the prayer of his word”. The phrase rules out two alternatives at once: that this is simply bread with a special meaning attached, and that the change is something the community achieves by its own faith or feeling.
If the iota slipped
If the bread were ordinary, the Eucharist would be a memorial meal, meaningful but without Christ himself. And if the change depended on the congregation’s faith, a distracted or doubting parish would receive less of Christ than a fervent one. Justin’s “by the prayer of his word” excludes that: the gift depends on Christ’s word, not our mood. Unexpectedly, that is what makes the Eucharist so consoling. It is there for the weak and the struggling as fully as for the saints.
Why it still matters
Justin’s account shaped Catholic worship more than most people realise. His order of readings, preaching, prayers, gifts, a great thanksgiving, the people’s Amen and Communion is the order of the Mass today. After the liturgy, he says, deacons took the Eucharist to those who were absent, as ministers now bring Communion to the sick and housebound after Sunday Mass. And a collection was taken for orphans, widows, the sick, prisoners and strangers: the ancestor of the Sunday collection.
Chew on this
Justin found “seeds of the Word” in pagan philosophy. Where do you see glimmers of truth outside the Church?
Some ways to answer
Justin taught that Christ, the Logos, is the source of all truth, so wherever people have grasped truth they have partly grasped him. He called these fragments “seeds of the Word”.
The Second Vatican Council took up his language: the Church rejects nothing that is true and holy in other religions, and recognises “seeds of the Word” in the world’s cultures. That doesn’t make every view equal. For Justin the seeds are partial and mixed with error, and are fulfilled only in Christ. The practical upshot is that Christians can engage philosophy, science and other traditions with confidence rather than fear.
Sources
What this bite draws on.
- Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 1–8 (his search through the philosophies)
- Justin Martyr, First Apology 65–67 (Sunday worship described for the emperor)
- Justin Martyr, First Apology 46; Second Apology 10 and 13 (the “seeds of the Word”)
Further reading
To take the question further.
- Second Vatican Council, Nostra Aetate 2 and Ad Gentes 11
- CCC 843
- CCC 1345–1347, which quotes Justin’s account