c. AD 400
In the Mass: Receiving Communion
Become what you receive
- In the Mass
- “The Body of Christ.” “Amen.” by c. AD 390 (Ambrose)
- Roots
- 1 Corinthians 10:16–17
Hippo, Pentecost, early in the fifth century. Seven weeks after their baptism at Easter, the newly baptised stand before Augustine at the Eucharist. He points to the altar and tells them what they are looking at: if you are the body of Christ and his members, it is your own mystery that is placed on the Lord’s table. You answer Amen to what you are. Be what you see, and receive what you are.
“The Body of Christ.” “Amen.” It may be the shortest creed there is. Around 390 Ambrose explained it to the newly baptised in Milan: the priest says “The Body of Christ”, and you say “Amen”, that is, “It is true.” Let your heart hold on to what your tongue confesses.
Cyril of Jerusalem offered the most practical advice: make your left hand a throne for your right, since it is about to receive a King, and take care not to lose a crumb.
The one iota
the Body of Christ, the Body of Christ
The same phrase names two realities: the Eucharist, and the Church. Augustine played on it deliberately: you receive the Body of Christ, and you are the Body of Christ. When you say “Amen”, you say it to both.
If the iota slipped
If “the Body of Christ” meant only the Eucharist, Communion would be a private encounter between me and Jesus, with no obligation to the people beside me. If it meant only the Church, the Eucharist would become a symbol of community rather than Christ himself. The unexpected danger of the first is individualism; of the second, the loss of the Real Presence. Augustine held both meanings together.
Why it still matters
Ambrose’s dialogue is still exactly how Communion is given: “The Body of Christ.” “Amen.” Cyril of Jerusalem’s advice to make the left hand a throne for the right shows that receiving in the hand, with great reverence, was the practice of his church; receiving on the tongue became usual in the West later. Both are permitted today. Cyril also describes the faithful receiving from the chalice, a practice widely restored after Vatican II.
Chew on this
Augustine says we become what we receive. What might that look like on a Monday morning?
Some ways to answer
The Eucharist doesn’t just nourish us; it changes us. In the Confessions Augustine imagines Christ saying: you will not change me into yourself, as with ordinary food; you will be changed into me. Becoming his Body means living as his hands, feet and heart wherever we are.
In practice that looks like ordinary charity, patience with difficult people, honesty at work, and care for the poor; the Catechism says plainly that the Eucharist commits us to the poor. Monday is where the Amen gets tested.
Sources
What this bite draws on.
- Augustine, Sermon 272 (“be what you see, and receive what you are”)
- Ambrose, On the Mysteries 54; On the Sacraments 4.25 (“Amen”, that is, “it is true”) (background)
- Cyril of Jerusalem, Mystagogical Catecheses 5.21–22 (a throne for the King, and the chalice)
- Augustine, Confessions 7.10 (“you will be changed into me”)
- 1 Corinthians 10:16–17 and 12:27 (one bread, one body)
- GIRM 160–161 (receiving in the hand or on the tongue)
- CCC 1396–1397 (the Eucharist and the poor)
Further reading
To take the question further.
- CCC 1391–1395