c. AD 200
In the Mass: The Lord’s Prayer
The prayer that sums up the whole Gospel
- In the Mass
- At Mass by c. AD 400; placed after the Canon by Gregory the Great, c. 600
- Roots
- Matthew 6:9–13; the Didache, c. AD 100
Carthage, around 200. As the ninth hour comes round in the middle of the afternoon, a Christian merchant pauses in the middle of his business. Like believers across the city, he prays the Lord’s Prayer, as Christians had done at set hours for generations. Tertullian, writing for people like him, calls it a summary of the whole Gospel.
The Our Father is the one prayer Jesus explicitly taught, and Tertullian, Cyprian and Origen all wrote whole treatises on it.
In the Roman Mass it sits between the Eucharistic Prayer and Communion; Gregory the Great placed it right after the Canon around 600. The Fathers loved to connect “give us this day our daily bread” with the Eucharist.
Ever wondered why Catholics stop after “deliver us from evil” while many other Christians carry straight on to “for the kingdom, the power and the glory”? That ending isn’t in the oldest manuscripts of Matthew; it was an early liturgical addition, and the Didache already has a form of it. At Mass the priest first expands the last petition (“Deliver us, Lord, we pray, from every evil…”), and then we all say the doxology anyway. Catholics say it too, just a paragraph later.
The one iota
“lead us not into temptation”
Taken literally, “lead us not into temptation” could suggest that God tempts us to sin, which James 1:13 denies. The early Latin Church already felt the difficulty: Tertullian and Cyprian quote the petition as “do not allow us to be led into temptation”. In recent years French-speaking Catholics adopted “do not let us enter into temptation” (2017) and Italians “do not abandon us to temptation” (2020). English keeps the ancient wording, understood in the same way.
If the iota slipped
What would genuinely undermine the faith is either of two extremes. A God who tempts people to sin would be the author of evil, and the petition would become a plea to a capricious deity. A Christian life with no testing at all would contradict the whole Bible, from Abraham to Gethsemane. The Fathers held the middle: God permits trials that strengthen us, and we ask not to be overcome, which is what every faithful translation tries to say.
Why it still matters
The Didache’s rule of the Our Father three times a day is still the Church’s rule. The General Instruction of the Liturgy of the Hours notes that the Lord’s Prayer is said solemnly at Morning Prayer, at Mass and at Evening Prayer, three times each day, in keeping with ancient tradition. And adults preparing for baptism are still formally “given” the Lord’s Prayer during Lent, as catechumens were in the early Church, before praying it for the first time with the faithful at the Easter Vigil.
Chew on this
Why pray “forgive us as we forgive” just before Communion?
Some ways to answer
Because Communion is communion with one another too. Jesus told us to leave our gift at the altar and first be reconciled (Matthew 5:23–24). The Our Father, then the sign of peace, then the Lamb of God: the whole rite moves us from being forgiven, to being reconciled, to being united.
It is also sobering: we ask God to forgive us in the same measure we forgive. Augustine taught that this petition, prayed sincerely each day, is how our everyday sins are healed. The Mass won’t let us receive Christ while ignoring the people Christ died for.
Sources
What this bite draws on.
- Tertullian, On Prayer 1 and 25 (a summary of the Gospel, and the hours of prayer)
- Cyprian, On the Lord’s Prayer (his commentary on the prayer; Treatise 4 on New Advent)
- Didache 8 (three times a day, with the doxology)
- Matthew 6:9–13 (the prayer Jesus taught)
- James 1:13 (God tempts no one)
- Gregory the Great, Letter to John of Syracuse (the Our Father after the Canon)
- General Instruction of the Liturgy of the Hours 195 (the Our Father three times daily)
- Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults (the presentation of the Lord’s Prayer) (background)
Further reading
To take the question further.
- Luke 11:2–4
- Matthew 5:23–24
- Augustine, Enchiridion 71
- CCC 2759–2865