One Iota

c. AD 110

The man who begged not to be rescued

καθολικήkatholikē, “universal”, “catholic”

Around AD 110, Ignatius, bishop of Antioch, was marched under guard to Rome to be thrown to wild beasts. Along the way he wrote seven letters: an ancient travel blog, only with more lions.

His request to the Christians of Rome was startling: please don’t try to get me off. “I am God’s wheat,” he wrote, “to be ground by the teeth of beasts, so that I may become the pure bread of Christ.”

In the same letters he calls the Eucharist the flesh of our Saviour, urges everyone to stay close to their bishop, and becomes the first writer we know of to use the phrase “the Catholic Church”. This is a man who may well have known people who knew the apostles. Whatever the earliest Church was, it was not vague.

The one iota

kath’ holou: “according to the whole”

Katholikos comes from kath’ holou, “according to the whole”. Ignatius uses it for a Church that is whole, not merely big: wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church. Around 350 Cyril of Jerusalem explained the word to his catechumens: the Church is catholic because it spreads through the whole world and teaches the whole of Christian doctrine, completely. The alternatives are to take “catholic” as a matter of size alone, or as a label for one party among others.

If the iota slipped

If “catholic” meant only “widespread”, the Church would be catholic by statistics, and could lose catholicity simply by shrinking. Worse, it would allow a Church that is large but partial, keeping only its popular doctrines. Kath’ holou means that even a small community gathered with its bishop at the Eucharist is fully catholic, because the whole Christ is there. The numbers definition makes the Church’s identity depend on success; the wholeness definition makes it depend on Christ.

Why it still matters

Ignatius is the first writer to describe clearly the threefold ministry of bishop, presbyters and deacons, and he told Christians to do nothing that concerns the Church without the bishop. That pattern still structures Catholic life. Every diocese is gathered around its bishop; priests preach and celebrate the sacraments with his authority; and the bishop remains the ordinary minister of Confirmation, the sacrament that completes Christian initiation. Ignatius’s letters read less like theory than like a description of a diocese.

Chew on this

Ignatius longed to become “the pure bread of Christ”. Holy, alarming, or both?

Some ways to answer

Both, and the Church has always held the two together. The Church never encourages anyone to seek death; the Martyrdom of Polycarp even criticises a man named Quintus who volunteered for martyrdom and then lost his nerve.

But Ignatius was already condemned. He wasn’t seeking death for its own sake; he was asking to be united with Christ’s sacrifice. His language is Eucharistic, not despairing: wheat ground to become bread. For Ignatius, discipleship means being conformed to Christ all the way.

Sources

What this bite draws on.

Further reading

To take the question further.

This is one of fifty five-minute bites in One Iota, an introduction to the people of the early Church and the prayers we still say at Mass.