c. AD 112
The first HR email about Christians
Pliny the Younger, Roman governor of Bithynia, had a problem, and did what every nervous middle manager does: he wrote to the boss. The boss happened to be the Emperor Trajan.
Christians keep being reported to me, Pliny explained. I have looked into it. They meet before dawn on a fixed day, sing a hymn to Christ as to a god, promise not to steal, cheat or commit adultery, and then share ordinary, harmless food. I can’t find an actual crime. I have executed some anyway, for being so stubborn. Did I do the right thing?
Trajan replied: don’t go hunting for them, ignore anonymous accusations, but if they are convicted and refuse to offer incense to the gods, punish them. Rome didn’t much care what you believed. It cared that you would burn a pinch of incense like everyone else. The Christians wouldn’t.
The one iota
nomen ipsum: “the name itself”
Pliny asked Trajan whether Christians should be punished for “the name itself”, even without any crime, or only for crimes linked to the name. Trajan’s answer in effect punished the name. The apologists protested exactly this: Justin and Tertullian argued that Christians were being condemned for a word, not a deed. The martyrs answered with two words of their own, Christianus sum, “I am a Christian”. The alternative was to deny the name, and live.
If the iota slipped
Many did deny it. In the persecution under Decius in 250, thousands obtained certificates saying they had sacrificed. The Church then argued fiercely over these “lapsed”: Novatian said they could never be readmitted, while others readmitted them at once. Cyprian and the Church of Rome took the middle path of real penance followed by reconciliation. The unexpected lesson is that the name is both demanding and merciful: denying Christ is grave, yet the Church does not abandon those who fall.
Why it still matters
Pliny noticed something else: Christians met before dawn “on a fixed day”. Sunday was a working day in the Roman world, so gathering meant rising early, and in times of persecution it could mean arrest. Around 304, martyrs at Abitina in North Africa told their judge they could not live without the Lord’s day. That conviction lies behind the Sunday obligation still asked of every Catholic, and behind the Catechism’s teaching that the Sunday Eucharist is the foundation of all Christian practice.
Chew on this
What is today’s “pinch of incense”: the small gesture everyone expects that a Christian might have to refuse?
Some ways to answer
Answers will vary, but the principle is clear. The incense wasn’t a trivial rite; it meant acknowledging a rival claim to ultimate allegiance. Christians honoured the emperor, prayed for him and paid their taxes, but would not worship him.
Modern equivalents are rarely so dramatic: affirming what one believes to be false, going along with what conscience cannot accept, or quietly making career and social acceptance the thing we really serve. The Church’s teaching gives the frame: respect legitimate authority, but never at the cost of what we owe to God.
Sources
What this bite draws on.
- Pliny the Younger, Letters 10.96–97 (the governor’s question and Trajan’s reply)
- Justin Martyr, First Apology 4 (Christians condemned for a name)
- Tertullian, Apology 2 (the same complaint)
- Acts of the Scillitan Martyrs (180) (“I am a Christian”)
- Cyprian, On the Lapsed (those who denied the faith under Decius; Treatise 3 on New Advent)
- Acts of the Martyrs of Abitina (304) (“we cannot live without the Lord’s day”) (background)
Further reading
To take the question further.
- Acts 5:29; Romans 13:1–7; 1 Peter 2:13–17
- Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae 2–3
- CCC 2104–2109 (religious freedom) and 2242 (when civil commands must be refused)
- CCC 2181, on the Sunday Eucharist