AD 416
In the Mass: The sign of peace
The kiss of peace, and why it moved
- In the Mass
- Placed before Communion in Rome by AD 416
- Roots
- Romans 16:16; Justin, c. AD 155
Gubbio, a small town in Umbria, around 416. Its bishop, Decentius, has been puzzled by the different customs visitors bring to his church, and writes to Pope Innocent I for guidance. Among his questions: when exactly should the kiss of peace be given? Innocent’s reply, which survives, is one of the earliest papal letters on the details of the liturgy.
Paul ends several letters with “Greet one another with a holy kiss” (Romans 16:16), and Justin reports Christians doing exactly that at Sunday worship around 155. In the early Church it usually came before the gifts were brought to the altar, following Jesus’ instruction: if your brother has something against you, first be reconciled, then come and offer your gift (Matthew 5:23–24).
Rome moved it. In 416 Pope Innocent I wrote that the peace should be given after the Eucharistic Prayer, as a seal on all that had gone before. So in the Roman Rite it sits just before Communion, joining peace with one another to communion with Christ.
Today it is usually a handshake, a bow or a nod, offered only to those nearby; there’s no need to work the room.
The one iota
philēma hagion: the holy kiss
Paul calls it a “holy kiss”, and the early Church took the adjective seriously. The Apostolic Tradition reserves it to the baptised, since a catechumen’s kiss is not yet holy. Athenagoras warned that it must be given with complete purity. Cyril of Jerusalem explained its meaning: a sign that souls are joined and every grudge put away. The alternatives are a mere social greeting, or leaving the sign out altogether.
If the iota slipped
As a social greeting, the peace becomes friendliness: warm with people we like, awkward with strangers, and empty of any demand. Leaving it out loses the one moment where the Mass asks us to act out reconciliation with the people actually present. Cyril’s meaning is more demanding than either: before receiving the one Body, we lay down our grievances against its members. The unexpected casualty of a merely social peace is forgiveness.
Why it still matters
Both ancient placements of the peace still exist. The Ambrosian Rite of Milan exchanges it before the gifts are offered, following Jesus’ words about being reconciled before bringing a gift to the altar. The Roman Rite keeps the place Innocent I defended, just before Communion. When the 2005 Synod of Bishops asked whether the Roman sign should be moved, the Holy See decided in 2014 to keep it where it has been since the fifth century, as a sign that the peace we share comes from Christ on the altar.
Chew on this
What if the person beside me is someone I’m not at peace with?
Some ways to answer
Then the sign of peace is meant precisely for you. Jesus’ instruction was to go and be reconciled (Matthew 5:23–24); the liturgical sign is a prayer and a promise to do that, not a pretence that it has already happened.
The peace we exchange is Christ’s, not ours, which is why we can offer it before we feel it. As Cyril saw, the gesture puts away the grudge; the reconciliation itself may take longer, but the Mass has begun it.
Sources
What this bite draws on.
- Romans 16:16 (“a holy kiss”)
- Justin Martyr, First Apology 65 (the kiss at Sunday worship)
- Matthew 5:23–24 (reconciled before the gift)
- Innocent I, Letter to Decentius (416) (the peace after the Eucharistic Prayer) (background)
- Apostolic Tradition 18 (not yet given by catechumens)
- Athenagoras, Plea for the Christians 32 (given with complete purity)
- Cyril of Jerusalem, Mystagogical Catecheses 5.3 (souls joined, grudges put away)
- Congregation for Divine Worship, circular letter on the sign of peace (2014) (kept in its Roman place)
- GIRM 82 and 154 (the rite of peace)
Further reading
To take the question further.