One Iota

AD 787

The icon-smashers and the monk out of reach

προσκύνησιςproskynēsis, literally “bowing down”: in Nicaea II’s sense, honorific veneration, as distinct from worship (latreia)

Constantinople, around 726 or 730. Above the Chalke Gate, the ceremonial entrance to the imperial palace, hangs a great icon of Christ. Soldiers arrive with ladders to take it down on the emperor’s orders. According to later tradition, a crowd of women gathered below and pulled away the ladder, and the officer fell to his death. Many historians now doubt the episode happened at all, and think Leo III did far less against icons than later writers claimed. But under his son Constantine V the campaign against images was real, and more than a century of struggle over holy images followed.

Images of Christ, the iconoclast emperors argued, broke the commandment against graven images.

The best reply came from John of Damascus, who, conveniently, lived under the Muslim caliphate, well out of the emperor’s reach, and could write what he liked. In the Old Testament, he argued, God was invisible, so of course no one could picture him. But now the invisible God has a face. “I do not worship matter,” he wrote. “I worship the Creator of matter, who became matter for my sake.”

In 787 the Second Council of Nicaea agreed. Worship belongs to God alone, but holy images deserve veneration, and the honour passes to the one they depict. Refuse to picture Christ, and you are quietly saying he never really took flesh.

The one iota

latreia / proskynēsis

Nicaea II drew a line between two Greek words: latreia, the adoration due to God alone, and what it called “honorific proskynēsis”, the veneration shown to holy images and saints. On its own, proskynēsis, literally “bowing down”, could mean either, which is why the council qualified it. English tends to blur both into “worship”, which is one reason Catholics are sometimes accused of idolatry. The distinction is the difference between God and everything else.

If the iota slipped

Collapse the two words one way, and all honour to images and saints becomes idolatry; the result is iconoclasm. Collapse them the other way, and veneration slides into worshipping creatures. The unexpected casualty of iconoclasm is Christ’s humanity: if he cannot be depicted, was he ever truly seen and touched (1 John 1:1)? The distinction protects both God’s uniqueness and the Word made flesh.

Why it still matters

The distinction shapes one of the most moving rites of the year. On Good Friday the faithful come forward to venerate the Cross, kissing it or bowing before it. Egeria saw the same rite in Jerusalem in the 380s, and noted that deacons stood guard because a pilgrim had once bitten off a piece of the relic. The Roman Missal calls it the “adoration” of the Cross, and Nicaea II explains why that is not idolatry: the honour passes through the wood to Christ, who alone is adored.

Chew on this

Is beauty in worship a luxury or a necessity?

Some ways to answer

The tradition leans strongly towards necessity, though not extravagance. Beauty is one of the ways truth reaches us: Pope Gregory the Great said that pictures give to the unlettered what writing gives to those who read. Beauty also draws the heart towards God before any argument does; Benedict XVI often spoke of the “way of beauty”.

The Church also warns against beauty that turns into display. Vatican II asked for noble beauty rather than mere sumptuous show. So beauty is necessary, but in the service of worship, not of ego.

Sources

What this bite draws on.

Further reading

To take the question further.

This is one of fifty five-minute bites in One Iota, an introduction to the people of the early Church and the prayers we still say at Mass.