c. AD 155
Did they really?
Two bishops who disagreed, and prayed together
Polycarp, the elderly bishop of Smyrna, travelled to Rome to see Pope Anicetus. They disagreed about the date of Easter, which the churches of Asia kept differently from Rome, and neither could persuade the other. But Anicetus invited Polycarp to celebrate the Eucharist in his own church, and they parted in peace.
What it tells us
Unity of faith never required uniformity of custom.
How it ended: In peace. A generation later Pope Victor threatened to cut off the Asian churches over the same question, until Irenaeus persuaded him otherwise.
Source: Irenaeus, quoted in Eusebius, Church History 5.24