AD 251
Did they really?
The theologian who would not forgive
Novatian, a Roman presbyter, wrote the finest Latin treatise on the Trinity of his day. But when the Church began readmitting, after penance, Christians who had lapsed in the persecution of Decius, he refused: the Church, he held, had no power to forgive such a sin. In 251 he had himself consecrated as a rival bishop of Rome against Pope Cornelius. His rigorist church outlived him by centuries.
What it tells us
Being right about the Trinity did not make Novatian right about mercy.
How it ended: Did not return; his schism lasted for centuries.
Source: Eusebius, Church History 6.43; Cyprian, Letters 44–55