AD 590
Did they really?
The pope who didn’t want the job
Rome was in the grip of plague when Gregory, a former city prefect turned monk, was elected pope. He wrote to the emperor begging him not to confirm the election, but the letter was intercepted. According to Gregory of Tours, he even tried to slip out of the city in hiding before he was found and brought back. As pope he complained that his soul was tossed about by the waves of business like an old ship.
What it tells us
Some of the greatest popes never wanted the office; Gregory’s reluctance was humility, not false modesty.
Source: Gregory of Tours, History of the Franks 10.1; Gregory the Great, Letters 1.5