One Iota

AD 335

Did they really?

The murder victim who turned up alive

At a synod in Tyre, Athanasius’s enemies accused him of murdering a bishop named Arsenius and keeping his severed hand for magic, and they produced a hand to prove it. Athanasius had Arsenius brought in, alive and wrapped in a cloak. He lifted one of the man’s arms, then the other, and asked the synod where the third hand had come from. He was condemned and exiled anyway. Not every charge against him was invented, though: a papyrus letter from 335 records complaints by the rival Meletian clergy that Athanasius’s supporters had beaten and imprisoned some of them.

What it tells us

Defending the faith didn’t make the Fathers popular, and church politics could be brutal.

Source: Socrates, Church History 1.29; Theodoret, Church History 1.30; London Papyrus 1914

This is one of the true stories in One Iota, which introduces the people of the early Church in five-minute bites.