c. AD 217
Did they really?
The “antipope” who died a saint
Hippolytus, a learned Roman presbyter, was, according to tradition, so outraged by Pope Callixtus’s readiness to forgive serious sinners that he broke with him, and his followers set him up as a rival bishop of Rome. Historians still debate who exactly he was, and whether he was ever truly an antipope. Years later, in 235, he and Pope Pontian were both deported to the mines of Sardinia. There, it seems, they were reconciled, and both died in exile. The Church honours them together as martyrs, on the same feast day.
What it tells us
Schism is not always the last word; reconciliation can come even in the mines.
How it ended: Reconciled; honoured as a martyr and saint.
Source: The Liberian Catalogue of Roman bishops; Roman Martyrology, 13 August