One Iota

AD 681

Not my will: the prayer in the garden

δύο θελήματα“two wills” (Constantinople, 681)

Constantinople, 655. An old monk stands before imperial officials, accused of treason for refusing the emperor’s compromise on the will of Christ. Everyone else, they tell him, is in communion with the patriarch. Maximus replies that even if the whole world were in communion with the patriarch, he would not be. He is sent into exile.

The compromise had seemed a neat idea: to heal the split after Chalcedon, say that Christ has two natures but only one will. Tidy. Diplomatic. Wrong, said Maximus.

Look at Gethsemane, he argued. Jesus shrinks from the cup, and then prays, “Not my will, but yours be done.” That is a real human will, freely saying yes to the Father. Take it away and Jesus never truly obeyed on our behalf, and our own wills are never healed.

In 662, when he was over eighty, his tongue and right hand were cut off so that he could neither speak nor write, and he died in exile that year. History simply calls him “the Confessor”. In 681 a council at Constantinople vindicated him, and also condemned a former pope, Honorius. Church history is many things, but never boring.

The one iota

one will, or two wills

The seventh-century dispute turned on a plural. The monothelites taught one will (thelēma) in Christ, and one “energy”, or activity. Maximus and the Third Council of Constantinople taught two natural wills, divine and human, not opposed to each other: the human will freely follows and submits to the divine.

If the iota slipped

One will in Christ sounds pious, but it makes Gethsemane unreal: God cannot obey God. Hebrews says Christ “learned obedience through what he suffered” (5:8), and Paul that by one man’s obedience many were made righteous (Romans 5:19). Without a human will there is no human obedience to undo Adam’s disobedience, and no truly human priest offering himself for us. The unexpected casualty is the Cross itself as a human act of love.

Why it still matters

The Church still keeps watch with Christ in his human anguish. On Holy Thursday, after the Mass of the Lord’s Supper, the faithful stay with the Blessed Sacrament at the altar of repose, answering Jesus’ question in Gethsemane: “Could you not watch with me one hour?” The Agony in the Garden also opens the Sorrowful Mysteries of the Rosary. Both practices assume what Maximus defended: the fear and the surrender in the garden were real, and worth accompanying.

Chew on this

Is a will perfectly united to God’s more free or less free? What do you mean by “free”?

Some ways to answer

It depends on what we mean by “free”. The modern default is that freedom means having options: the more choices, the freer. Maximus, with the Fathers, sees freedom as the power to choose the good and reach it. A virtuoso is freer at the keyboard than a beginner, who is only free to make noise.

Sin, on this view, is not freedom but slavery (John 8:34). In Gethsemane Christ’s human will is at its freest: it feels the full weight of fear and still chooses love. The Catechism says it directly: the more one does what is good, the freer one becomes.

Sources

What this bite draws on.

Further reading

To take the question further.

This is one of fifty five-minute bites in One Iota, an introduction to the people of the early Church and the prayers we still say at Mass.