c. AD 530
Did they really?
The abbot his monks tried to poison
Before founding Monte Cassino, Benedict was persuaded to become abbot of a community of monks near Vicovaro. He turned out to be far stricter than they had bargained for, so they put poison in his wine. According to Gregory the Great, when Benedict made the sign of the cross over the jug, it shattered as if struck by a stone. Benedict told the monks to find an abbot more to their liking, and left.
What it tells us
Reform is rarely welcome, even in a monastery.
Source: Gregory the Great, Dialogues 2.3