c. AD 49
Did they really?
Peter, Paul and an awkward meal
In Antioch, Peter shared meals with Gentile Christians, setting aside the Jewish Law’s rules about eating with Gentiles. When men arrived from James in Jerusalem, he quietly withdrew to eat only with Jewish believers, and even Barnabas followed. The unspoken message to the Gentiles: become Jews if you want a full place at the table. Paul confronted Peter in front of everyone. You no longer live by the Law yourself, he said, so how can you pressure Gentiles to keep it? For Paul this was the Gospel itself: we are made right with God through faith in Christ, not by keeping the Law.
What it tells us
Even the chief apostle could be publicly corrected, and the Church kept the story.
How it ended: Reconciled, as the early Church remembered it: around AD 96, 1 Clement honours Peter and Paul together as the Church’s greatest pillars, and 2 Peter calls Paul “our beloved brother”.
Source: Galatians 2:11–14; 1 Clement 5; 2 Peter 3:15–16