One Iota

c. AD 172

Did they really?

Justin’s pupil who went his own way

Tatian, a Syrian, became a Christian under Justin Martyr in Rome and wrote a fierce defence of the faith. He also produced the Diatessaron, a single harmonised Gospel woven from the four, which Syrian churches read for centuries, until a fifth-century bishop collected some two hundred copies and replaced them with the four Gospels. After Justin’s martyrdom Tatian returned to the East and drifted into a severe sect, the Encratites, which rejected marriage, meat and wine. Irenaeus lists him among the heretics.

What it tells us

The Church kept the four Gospels because they came from the apostles and their companions; a blend, however convenient, was no longer their witness.

How it ended: Did not return, as far as we know.

Source: Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1.28.1; Theodoret, Compendium of Heretical Fables 1.20

This is one of the true stories in One Iota, which introduces the people of the early Church in five-minute bites.