One Iota

434–1845

Your baby photos are still you

eodem sensu eademque sententia“in the same sense and the same meaning” (Vincent of Lérins)

An island off the coast of Gaul, near modern Cannes, around 434. In the monastery of Lérins, a monk named Vincent sits down to write a notebook, the Commonitorium, under a modest pen-name: Peregrinus, “the Pilgrim”. Three years after the Council of Ephesus, he wants a simple rule for telling true doctrine from novelty, and he finds one: what has been believed everywhere, always, and by all. That sounds as though nothing may ever change.

But Vincent also said that doctrine grows the way a child grows into an adult: bigger, stronger, more articulate, and still the same person. Your baby photos are still you.

Fourteen centuries later, John Henry Newman, an Anglican trying to decide whether the Catholic Church of his day was the Church of the Fathers, set out marks for telling genuine growth from corruption. He concluded that it was, and became a Catholic. “To live is to change,” he wrote, “and to be perfect is to have changed often.” The councils did not add to the faith. They found words for what the Church had always held.

The one iota

eodem sensu: “in the same sense”

Vincent allowed doctrine to grow, but only “in the same doctrine, the same sense and the same meaning”. The First Vatican Council quoted his words directly. That small phrase is the test: growth that keeps the same sense is development; growth that changes it is something else.

If the iota slipped

If doctrine could grow in a different sense, the Church could come to teach the opposite of what she once taught, and every doctrine would become provisional; no Catholic could be sure the Creed will mean the same thing tomorrow. Unexpectedly, refusing all growth undermines the faith too: it would make the councils themselves illegitimate, since “consubstantial” was new wording at Nicaea. Vincent’s phrase guards against both: no reversal, and no freezing.

Why it still matters

Much of the renewal after Vatican II was a return to the early Church rather than a break with it. The adult catechumenate, restored in 1972, is modelled on the preparation of converts in the third and fourth centuries. The Prayer of the Faithful, Communion under both kinds, concelebration, and new Eucharistic Prayers built on ancient ones all drew on the Fathers. That is Vincent’s principle in action: the Church grows by recovering what was always hers, in the same sense.

Chew on this

How could you tell whether a change in the Church is growth or corruption?

Some ways to answer

Newman offered seven marks, which he called notes: preservation of type (it remains recognisably the same faith), continuity of principles, power of assimilation (it can take in what is true from outside without losing itself), logical sequence (it grows logically from what came before), anticipation of its future (it was hinted at earlier), conservative action upon its past (it preserves rather than reverses past teaching), and chronic vigour (it lasts and stays alive). Vincent’s image helps: a child grows, but never grows extra limbs or loses the ones it had.

In Catholic teaching the final judgement belongs to the Church’s teaching office, which is bound by Scripture and Tradition rather than above them. A simple test for the rest of us: does a change make the older teaching clearer, or does it require us to say the older teaching was false?

Sources

What this bite draws on.

Further reading

To take the question further.

This is one of fifty five-minute bites in One Iota, an introduction to the people of the early Church and the prayers we still say at Mass.